Salary comparison
First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers: New York vs Vineland
Vineland, NJ pays about 11.9% more for first-line supervisors of construction trades and extraction workers on paper — $116,390 vs $103,990. But once you factor in what it costs to live there, Vineland comes out ahead by $12,400 a year in real buying power.
New York, NY
$103,990
$81,180
$131,670
$50.00
100
$103,990/yr
Median adjusted for local cost of living.
Vineland, NJ
$116,390
$84,390
$129,630
$55.96
100
$116,390/yr
Median adjusted for local cost of living.
What the numbers mean in practice
The headline gap is $12,400 a year (11.9%) in favor of Vineland. That is the raw salary difference before any living costs.
New York runs a cost index of 100 against the national baseline of 100; Vineland sits at 100. After adjusting the median for those costs, Vineland is the better deal by $12,400 a year — that is what each paycheck actually buys locally.
If you are weighing a move from New York to Vineland for this role, the raise needs to beat 11.9% to come out ahead after living costs. Anything below that and you are earning more on paper but keeping less.
Common questions
Where do first-line supervisors of construction trades and extraction workers earn more, New York or Vineland?
Vineland pays $116,390 on median — about 11.9% more than New York ($103,990). Based on BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics.
Which city is the better deal after living costs?
Vineland. Once you divide each median by the local cost index, Vineland gives you roughly$116,390 of real buying power versus $103,990 in the other city.